I have a few great friends. One in particular I met across the country at a somewhat boring party, just as I was about to become despondent and rule out the possibility of meeting anyone interesting. I think I overheard him say "Animal Collective", and I immediately jumped over a couch to introduce myself to my new friend. After a few minutes of conversation we talked about music and dropped names like there was no tomorrow. Something interesting I noted though, was his distinction between calling something his "favorite" or "best" of the (year, all time, etc). He later explained the importance of the difference between the two. I'm not sure if I necessarily agreed, but I became 'aware' of something I before hadn't given much thought... the idea of 'thinking' about music.
Thinking about music, to me, is just as important as listening to music. Allowing your brain to take precedence over your ears can make music so much more of an enjoyable experiance. And I think being able to apply quantintative value to an art such as music, the criterion for judging lies in a sweet spot between "favorite" and "best". For instance, I think that without a doubt Subtle's album was the "best" of the year. But that doesn't mean that Island's album didn't bring me more joy, or will be subject to more listens. That being said, enough with the rambling, lets see some numbers!!!
1)
Subtle - for hero: for fool

If you haven't yet familiarized yourself with the Anticon label, please do yourself a favor and do so immediately. Anticon specializes in smart, experimental, white boy hip hop. 75% of the groups are mediocre, while the other 25% (those sharing a lot of key members) are amazing. Subtle is composed of the label's finest MC and beat master, along with familiar faces on keyboards, guitar, cello, and sax.
This album could be described in one word: ferocious. It leaps out of the gate with the energy of ATDI's "Relationship of Command", and keeps the gas pedal floored through most of the album, while still allowing space for moments of beauty, spaced perfectly through the album. Like ATDI, many elistist fans I've heard from prefer the groups earlier work. But to those not grounded in past, for hero: for fool showcases the groups most cohesive and inviting music to date. Personally, I've never been so obsessed with every morsel of sound on an album. Subtle has honed such a fine craft here, and presents it in such an interesting and unorthadox manner. I cannot stress enough what a good investment it is to spend time with this album.
2)
Belle & Sebastian - The Life Pursuit

Belle & Sebastian are among my favorite bands. And I'm not sure if this helped or hindered their ranking on this list. While providing many "my favorite band just released an amazing new album" feelings, I still turn a blind eye to the fact that nothing they do will ever provide life changing nostalgia like their early singles / EPs, or hearing them for the first time on "Dear Catastrophe Waitress". Its a sad curse that plauges them, along with Modest Mouse, Beck, Malkmus, etc forever. But in the end you need to just set it aside and realize... this album is really really good.
3)
Islands - Return to the Sea

Gorgeous in layers that unfold with time. Each song is an adventure. Its only flaw is its perhaps greatest attribute: youthful ambition. Plus it has some of my """favorite!!""" drumming of alltime.
4)
Fiery Furnaces - Bitter Tea

Quite possibly my top record of the year if 3-4 songs were shaved off. Bitter Tea is a more mature and wise Furnaces, but noticeably weary from its 2 albums a year pace. It showcases some of their best blending of experimental goofiness with pop brilliance, but ultimately Friedberger has too many idea for his own good.
5)
I'm From Barcelona - Let Me Introduce My Friends

This album is the equivalent of the most beautiful and intriguing landscape painting you've ever seen at a friend's apartment. Perfectly executed craft, endlessly enjoyable.
6)
NAVE! - NAVE02

At first I thought it would be cute to throw my friend Evan in here, who released an album under his moniker earlier in March. But then I realized that NAVE02 was really the 6th most enjoyable album I've come across this year. NAVE! specializes in producer based music that has an absolute sense of space and timing. Listening to this album is like riding an amusement park ride, and the theme is NAVE!'s dense musical influences. And at the end you feel like a better person for making it through.
7)
Sunset Rubdown - Shut Up I Am Dreaming

Stadiums and Shrines II @ 0:56.
8)
Joanna Newsom - Ys
9)
The Flaming Lips - At War With The Mystics
10)
Beck - The Information